I Can Stop Any Time I Want, or, Jaiwatch Part III

Hatred motivates obsession: I first learned this at Schuler Books in Grand Rapids, MI. The guys who worked in the stockroom were as liberal as they come, but they listened to Rush Limbaugh religiously. They hated everything he said, but they couldn’t get enough of him. Every day they tuned in to his show in order to feed, inform, and clarify their hatred.

Now, I don’t hate Jai, who I have written about once or twice before. But it’s a similar dynamic that keeps me coming back to “Queer Eye for the Straight Guy”:http://www.bravotv.com/Queer_Eye_for_the_Straight_Guy/. This week’s episode, where the Fab Five try to reconstruct a certifiably psychotic tightwad named Alan, only confirms my conviction that Jai must be ejected from the show at the earliest opportunity, or Western civilization will collapse.

In the first segment, we see Jai following the other guys around, nosing in on their business. His words of wisdom regarding Alan’s entertainment center: “This is fancy here, what you’ve got going on here.” Later on he makes fun of one of Alan’s books: “‘Idiot’s Guide to Beer’?! Who’s that much of an idiot that they need a _guide_ to beer?” Of course, said book is a guide to _brewing_ beer, which is exactly the kind of thing you might expect the “Culture” expert to know something about.

Jai sings. That’s grounds for eviction right there. It’s part of a highly pathetic jam session. Here are the clever lyrics he improvises: “Five gay men and one straight man in the house. / That’s all it takes.” Keep in mind that this is what the show’s editors present to us _after_ sifting through who knows what else. This is what they thought represented Jai _best_.

The bone the producers throw Jai this time around is to take Alan to shop for a gift for his girlfriend. Of Satya, the store he chooses, he has this to say: “This is the best place to come because everything is unusual and _so_ unique.”

His advice to Alan before the party: “Offer your guests drinks when they arrive.” “Make them feel comfortable.” Stunning.

The kicker is that we can’t really blame Jai for the absolute disaster Alan makes of the evening in the final segment. No amount of work or advice could have prevented him from mucking things up. Still, we have here yet another episode in which Jai does absolutely nothing to reform the weekly guinea pig. He can’t act, by which I mean that he always seems like he’s acting despite the fact that no one is actually supposed to be performing a role. This is ironic because, according to the website, Jai is the only one of the Five who is a professional actor.

The show is crumbling. This week’s episode was once again rife with conspicuous product placements and endorsements. It’s becoming clear that Carson is not merely annoying, but has no actual fashion sense. Thom remains brilliant, and Ted wins big points for singing the praises of the martini, but the two of them alone cannot sustain the show. It’s going to crumble, and I’m not going to be able to avert my eyes while it does. It’s the First Law of Reality Television: “Everybody likes watching a train wreck.”

Smiling Dog Guy

I generally try to avoid the waiting room at the Jiffy Lube, but today I mis-timed my arrival and found myself there for a few minutes while they finished working on the Polytroposmobile. I had just decided against reading the cheesy article about Bangkok in a wrinkled travel magazine when the door opened and a peculiar smell wafted in. The smell of dog.

Now then: I am a cat person, or at least as much as anyone can be who doesn’t actually own a cat. The inevitable corollary to this is that I am _not_ a dog person. This is true in spite of the fact that I know and love some dogs and even more dog people. I have made my peace with the fact that dogs are among us, but it is a fragile peace, one that threatens to crack when dogs enter places like Jiffy Lube waiting rooms.

I’m not hypersensitive to foul odors or anything; this dog objectively stank. A middle-aged man with a big smile and a bow tie followed it in and sat down directly across from me. His smile remained plastered on as he tried to make eye contact. He wore a sign around his neck that read:

I WANT TO TALK ABOUT MY DOG

On reflection, there might not have been an actual sign there, but he didn’t need one. He kept looking at me, and I experienced “a curious sense of deja vu”:http://www.polytropos.org/archives/000065.html. He was waiting for me to look at his dog, maybe pet it, at least _acknowledge_ it. I did my best to avoid looking at the dog, but this was difficult, because the dog was trying to chew on my sandal. Why oh why had I set down my magazine?

Another guy walked into the waiting room. I knew right away he was a dog person because he didn’t immediately gag at the smell of dirty dog that by now was seeping into the furniture. Instead, he kneeled down to scratch the dog on the head.

It was as if someone had thrown a switch on Smiling Dog Guy. He had been waiting for this moment. “Isn’t she lovely? Yeeess. Gooood dog. Goood dog. I’m not sure exactly what she is . . . oh, she’s a mutt, I know, part terrier part sheep dog they usually say, but she’s a goood dog and we love her don’t we oh yes sweeetums yes we dooo yes we dooo.”

I was hoping the new guy would recoil in shock at this strange behavior, but instead he just smiled. “Part terrier part sheepdog. Mah uncle in Alabama had one just lahk this.”

And they were off. My eyes were beginning to water from the smell, and I quickly lost track of the train of their dialogue, which wasn’t so much a conversation as an alternating series of exclamations about this dog and dogs in general. Smiling Dog Guy always followed his by petting the dog and saying “Goooood Dog” or “We love you yes don’t we oh we do.” A couple minutes in, his emotion overcame him and he actually _picked the dog up into his lap_. It was really too big for that sort of thing, but this didn’t stop him.

A young woman entered at that point and wrinkled her nose, God bless her. Briefly, she took in the scene: Man One, holding a big dog in his lap. Man Two, kneeling at Man One’s feet, where the dog had just been. Man Three, seeing if he could teleport himself away from there by sheer force of will. She smiled politely and retreated out of the waiting room, which, I realized, I should have done a while back.

“Excuse me, sir, would it kill you wash your dog once in a while? Especially if you bring it in public? And when it tries to gnaw my toe off, maybe not treat the situation as if it’s highly amusing? And in the name of all that is beautiful in this broken world of ours, lose the freakin’ bow tie.”

That isn’t what I said. No, I didn’t say anything. I was pathetic: I pretended I was making a cell phone call and headed outside for better reception, whereupon I actually did make a call in order to have an excuse to stay outside until they called my name.

I already know what my punishment is going to be for my uncharitable attitude. Years hence, my as-yet-unborn child will look at me with unrefuseable eyes and say “Daddy! I want a puppy!”

Greg Costikyan Finds the Master, Part II

What I should have done yesterday, before responding to Greg’s notes on My Life With Master, was to actually read his essay Where Stories End and Games Begin, which he claims is refuted somewhat by MLWM. But I didn’t, and (as Ed pointed out) I also was sloppy in my use of the term “narrativist.” Hopefully what follows will rectify things and not just muddy the waters even more.

When we were kids, I used to tell my little brother Colin stories that he called “Chooseyers.” The impetus came from Choose Your Own Adventure books, which we both enjoyed. When we had run through all of those we could find, I tried making them up on the fly for him, giving him two or choices for how the story could continue every few minutes. This evolved quite quickly into completely open-form storytelling, where Colin took on the role of the protagonist and I took on the role of everything else. We were, in essence, engaged in a roleplaying game—one with no rules or structure of any kind.

The funny thing is that at the same time I was playing “real” roleplaying games, Star Frontiers and Marvel Super Heroes and Dungeons & Dragons, and it didn’t even occur to me that these activities and “Chooseyers” were basically the same thing. It wasn’t until years later, when I started playing Amber, that it hit me.

What’s relevant here is that the whole notion of a “roleplaying game” doesn’t require any of the basic things we usually associate with a “game.” One could argue that at the level of a Chooseyer, what’s going on is no longer a game but simply collaborative storytelling. But this doesn’t strike me as useful, because those Chooseyers clearly have much more in common with D&D than D&D does with Scrabble, or even with a game like Talisman. Storytelling is integral to roleplaying games.

In “Where Stories End and Games Begin”, Greg Costikyan argues that

Even the best games have to compromise the nature of “the game” in order to work as storytelling environments at all. Designing or writing here, at the intersection of story and game, is an interesting exercise, but fraught with peril and unhappy compromises. That is true because story is the antithesis of game. The best way to tell a story is in linear form. The best way to create a game is to provide a structure within which the player has freedom of action. Creating a “storytelling game” (or a story with game elements) is attempting to square the circle, trying to invent a synthesis between the antitheses of game and story. Precisely because the two things—game and story—stand in opposition, the space that lies between them has produced a ferment of interesting game-story hybrids. And yet the fact remains: game and story are in opposition, and any compromise between the two must struggle to be successful.

This holds true for a lot of games, but not for roleplaying games, whose very purpose is to merge story and game. In a roleplaying game, the story is generated by all the players collectively, and exists only ephemerally in the context of the gaming session. This is one of the reasons that Greg downplays the role of “story” in paper RPGs:

These “stories” are meaningful to players precisely because they are intimately involved. Players frequently write up “expedition reports,” in which they retell the story of a particular session of play, or several sessions. Expedition reports almost invariably make dull reading for those who are not involved in the campaign, because they do not have the same intimate familiarity with the setting, the same long history with the players and their characters.

The fact that most RPG sessions will generate what is, by literary standards, a bad story doesn’t make it any less a story. The purpose of the story in this case is the enjoyment of the participants only, who, because they’re invested in specific roles as well as the general creation of the story, are likely to have fun (and even appreciate the event aesthetically) even if the story that comes out of it isn’t going to interest anyone else.

It’s like a hootenanny, or at least like the ones I’ve attended in the basement of Marist Hall. People come by; some bring instruments. I play the bongoes. Some of the people there know how to play music; others, like me, are rank amateurs. The output of those sessions isn’t going to win any recording contracts, and might even get laughed off the stage at some open-mic nights. But for everyone who’s taking part, it’s grand fun, and on certain rare occasions even transcendent (bolstered by enough alcohol, of course).

The point here is that an RPG is not an instance of a game doing story badly; it’s doing what it’s supposed to do, which is a different kind of story. In one sense, narrativists are people who see the goal of an RPG as being to get that story as close to literary quality as possible.

Moreover, the rhythm of a roleplaying game is not the rhythm of a short story; you have peaks of excitement and periods of boredom and things happening here and there. You don’t have a long build leading to catharsis; you have gradual character evolution instead. The closest non-interactive analog is, perhaps, a “series” comic book—a comic with a small cast of characters who have adventures together, some of them short one-issue stories and others with story arcs that are told over several issues.

I don’t think anyone would dispute that a serial comic would count as a kind of story; I certainly don’t think that “gradual character evolution” and a lack of “a long build leading to catharsis” make something cease to be a story.

Many role-playing gamers never give “story” a second thought—they get their kicks from solving problems and playing roles, they don’t terribly mind whether the things they encounter knit together into some kind of coherent story. For them, that isn’t their main interest in the game.

This is certainly true of many roleplayers, with the narrativists crowded at the other end of the spectrum. But their lack of interest in story doesn’t change the fact that it’s the presence of a story that the players themselves create that distinguishes RPGs from other types of games.

The unique nature of RPGs gets blurred by the existence of computer games that call themselves “roleplaying games” as well. But there�s an important distinction between the sort of story created by a roleplaying game and that created by a computer RPG, a computer adventure game, or even a MMORPG. In all the latter cases, there is no element of performance, no true open-endedness, and (most importantly) a yawning gap between the creator (of the story) and the player. The designers of a game may be telling a story that coexists happily beside the game, and in some cases may do it very well, as with Grim Fandango and Deus Ex. But a game with multiple paths to success and even multiple endings, like Deus Ex, is still telling the story of its designers; its story element sinks or swims based on how original and interesting their ideas are, and on the quality of the writing and the graphic design within the game. The player’s contributions may satisfy them on a gaming level, but on a story level they are merely an audience.

In summary: in roleplaying games, game and story exist harmoniously. This is true of all RPGs to some extent; My Life With Master, because it’s so innovative and unusual, just makes it that much clearer. Ed Heil does a good job pointing out what makes MLWM unique:

But what I think is interesting about games like My Life With Master, as well as many other games of its little-known kind, is not that they don’t have very many rules. It’s that the rules they have attempt to support narrativist play over and above the other kinds of play (simulationist and gamist).

In other words, the rules of MLWM create a situation where you have to pay attention to the story that’s developing; if you don’t, you’re not really playing the game.

I have at least three tangents in my head, clamoring for attention, all having to do with the line between RPGs and computer RPGs. I�m going to save them for another day, though.

Quicksilver Wiki

Via “Crooked Timber”:http://www.crookedtimber.com/ : Neal Stephenson has set up a “Wiki for Quicksilver”:http://www.metaweb.com/wiki/wiki.phtml. Basically a place for the community at large to provide annotations and background. Cool idea.

The book is out, and all kinds of people are reading it right now, and I’m not because I was stupid and ordered it on Amazon. What was I thinking?

It will be arriving in a box that also contains “What To Expect the First Year”:http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/tg/detail/-/0894805770/qid=1064425752/sr=8-1/ref=sr_8_1/002-5302622-9575239?v=glance&s=books&n=507846. Crikey.

UPDATE: Regarding the wiki: look also at Neal’s description of the project, which makes it clear that it’s a little more ambitious than a standard wiki, in some interesting ways.

Testing . . .

_If this actually works_, then I am a *big* fan of:

# The “MT-Textile”:http://www.bradchoate.com/past/mttextile.php Plugin
# The “Smarty Pants”:http://www.daringfireball.net/projects/smartypants/ Plugin

bq. Both for Movable Type.

UPDATE: Seems to work — except for an extra space above the blockquote. Still, I’m happy.

Greg Costikyan Finds the Master

Greg Costikyan has picked up on what Ed Heil and I have known for a while — My Life With Master is very cool. Greg’s not approaching the game steeped in narrativist RPGs like Ed and I, which gives him a fresh perspective.

Ed linked to it before me, but I think Greg’s taken aback by more than just the fact that MLWM is narrativist. It’s the predetermined structure of the narrative that fascinates him. He conflates the significance of the game’s narrativism and its determinism, though:

In a standard RPG, player action is tightly constrained on a moment to moment basis . . . In Master, by contrast, there are no literal constraints on action, on a moment-by-moment basis; there are no systems to resolve the success or failure of actions, so that the only real constraint is gamemaster acquiescence, which is unlikely to be withheld unless you are doing someting inappropriate from the perspective of narrative coherence. On the other hand, the narrative is highly constrained; inevitably, Master will die, and each character will achieve or suffer one of five possible outcomes.

Everything but the last sentence is true of any game with a narrative, low-mechanics focus, and will be intimately familiar to fans of games like Amber or Nobilis. It’s the last bit that makes MLWM unusual — whether or not the word “groundbreaking” is appropriate here, I’m not sure. I can’t think of another RPG that consciously frames the entire plot arc of a story and leaves only the characters and details to the players.

. . . it is true that a power gamer will find little to like in this style of game, where outcomes are essentially predetermined, with minor fluctuations allowed. But if I were to sit down with a group of 13 year-olds who had never played any RPG before, I don’t know that I would have any more difficulty getting them into this type of game than D&D… It requires a somewhat different mindset, is all. Improv rather than dungeon-crawling.

All this could easily be applied to any narrative-oriented game, though it holds even more true for MLWM. But Greg’s right — those thirteen year-olds can take to a storytelling game just as easily as to a conventional, task-and-rule oriented one. I saw it happen all the time when I ran demos of Once Upon a Time for Atlas Games.

I have one rules thought on MLWM itself. Greg assumes that the game only allows for three different types of scenes: the Master gives a command; the minion carries it out (or doesn’t); the minion makes an overture to one of the townsfolk. Whether these are, in fact, the only types of scenes, and in what order they should come, is one of the things that the rules don’t adequately explain. When we played the game at Gencon we ran into situations where the ongoing story called for scenes to happen that didn’t fit nicely into that framework. If I were going to run this game at some point (and I hope I get the chance), I’d loosen things up considerably in terms of types of scenes while still maintaining a clear structure for who gets to call for scenes when.

Anyway, though Greg has stumbled across narrativist RPGs via their oddest possible example, he finds his way to an intriguing analogy:

. . . I wonder if this is an example of the “photography > abstract art” phenomenon. By which I mean that once photography was possible, painting was forced to respond by finding something to do other than producing realistic images of real-world things: photography could do that better than someone daubing in oils. I’m sensitive to the criticism that I’m a technological determinist, and I’m sure there were other cultural forces–but really, it seems so obvious.

In this case, I wonder whether the advent of MMGs, which do a pretty good (far from ideal, but not bad) job of satisfying the same jones as classic RPGs–with really pretty graphics, albeit much inferior storytelling–is forcing tabletop RPG designers away from the classic RPG style and toward styles that reward real storytelling, which nothing digital (despite Chris Crawford’s best efforts) can provide as tenth as well as a skilled GM.

It’s an interesting theory, but I’m not sure if it’s really happening, though. The advent of story-focused roleplaying, whether you place that with Ars Magica or Amber or wherever, happened a long time before the advent of MMORPGs. It’s still going strong now, but I haven’t noticed any shift in the number of narrativist games or players since the rise of Ultima Online and Everquest. (If anything, the only recognizable dynamic there is the familiar complaint that “Evercrack” is distracting lots of people from all the other games they used to play.) MMORPGs got big right around the same time as third edition D&D, which was an exuberant and explicit return to the good ol’ dungeon crawl, not a push toward story-oriented play.

While MMORPGs (or just computer RPGs in general) may replace tabletop RPGs in the sense that gamers spend time playing computer games instead of gaming face-to-face, they are not really the same “type” of game, don’t exercise the same muscles, and are, in the most important ways, a fundamentally different experience. This is true even if the tabletop game in question is a highly structured dungeon-crawling affair where the players are mostly concerned about leveling up. Even in that situation, a couple factors will make the tabletop gaming different. First, the fact that there’s a human GM means that the narrative is literally open-ended — new material can be generated on the fly, and rules can be adjudicated and changed as necessary to describe or account for, literally, anything imaginable. Second, the actual act of roleplaying, of behaving (or at the very least speaking) in character around people who are right there with you, is something that MMORPGs don�t duplicate. (I don’t want to say “can�t” because I know from my old NarniaMUSH days that text-based online roleplaying can, in theory, sustain a very strong performative element. But that sort of thing was predicated on virtual worlds where there were no respawning goblin lairs at the end of the path — description and performance were their entirety. Certainly the addition of graphics and a 3D environment, at least at the current stage of the technology, makes virtual role-playing harder, not easier.)

So: I don’t think people will turn to narrativist games because computer games fill the “dungeon-crawling” gap; I think they’ll always turn to tabletop roleplaying to fill a niche that computer games don’t, and within that niche some will prefer the narrativist style and others won’t.

I�m finding myself in deep water here, since there’s the fact that MMORPGs do engender community and interpersonal reaction in important ways. But I’ll have to leave it for another time, or just leave it entirely since I’m not playing any MMORPGs at the moment so I don’t have any direct experience to speak from.

In the last section of his entry, Greg brings up his own ludological perspective and the ways that My Life With Master refutes his argument on the subject. I think he’s on to something in that, by constraining some aspects of the narrative, the game allows for more freedom in telling the story at the scene-by-scene level. In an ideal narrativist world, would the players agree on the narrative constraints and not need rules or dictums to help enforce it? No, I think the rules have some intrinsic value as well — there’s art in the artifice of providing a context for group storytelling and shaping the story in a particular way.

And it’s also not at all evident to me how you go about “enforcing narrative consistency while permitting freedom of action in other spheres” in digital media.

I can’t see how it would work either. I think this is One of Those Things that make tabletop RPGs a whole different kahuna. While I realize that Greg was talking about MLWM specifically here, I think it speaks to a particular kind of flexibility that’s unique to traditional RPGs.

There are lot of other tangents to consider from here, but I’ll save them for another day. One quibble: I’m betting Czege has read Castle of Otranto. Suffice it to say: Greg, glad to hear you think this game rocks, too.

UPDATE: More talk on this subject can be found in Part II, here.

Endless Nights Rundown

Endless Nights seems to be getting an awful lot of attention. Dirk Deppey refers to it as the “Neil Gaiman media juggernaut.” Why all the press? Here’s my theory: the throngs of sensitive English-major types who adored Sandman while they were in college are now the mid-30’s editors and writers churning out the bulk of the nation�s media content. They’ve got some pull, so when Vertigo launches a strong publicity campaign, they respond. In droves.

And a good thing, too, I say. On second reading, I liked Endless Nights even more, though that’s not to say that I don’t have quibbles. Let’s have a look at each of the stories in turn.

“Death and Venice”
Art by P. Craig Russell

The first three stories are clearly the top three of the bunch, though I’m hard put to pick a favorite among them. This one is the longest, and of all seven the one that holds tightest to its subject — that is to say, it’s about not just Death, but death. I loved the depictions of Death herself, as well as the different styles in which Russell draws the present day, the Duke’s court, and the soldier’s memories. This story is classic Sandman: it takes a mythological conceit (the Duke’s court cheats Death, who waits for them outside the gate but cannot enter enter until another opens the way for her) and fleshes it out with the mundane and the personal (our protagonist and his understated listlessness and doubt about life as a soldier).

The story goes on for exactly one page too long. The bottom of page 33 is a fine stopping point; everything after is just overdone moodiness. Here’s the last line: “I shiver, and hurry from the square, as the darkness of the city closes over me like canal water or the grave.” Pick your metaphor, dude. This is not the prose of the guy who wrote American Gods.

“What I’ve Tasted of Desire”
Art by Milo Manara

Say it with me now: it’s not about the nekkidness. It’s not about the nekkidness. OK, maybe a little about the nekkidness. Certainly Manara is a master of the erotic, and his art fits perfectly in a story about Desire. There’s a great folk tale at the core of this one, even if Desire herself is somewhat tacked-on. The facial expressions on pages 52-53 alone are worth the price of admission.

Friendly tip: if you’re reading this story in your favorite coffee shop, take care about who’s watching over your shoulder. Otherwise ‘bound to have to do a lot of explaining to the innocent young person who works there and now thinks you’re some kind of perv. “But, see, it’s Sandman! It’s art! Really!”

“The Heart of a Star”
Art by Miguelanxo Prado

Unlike the first two, you really need a familiarity with Sandman to appreciate this story. It’s one for the fans, providing glimpses of the early manifestations of the Endless: a rare glimpse of Delight; the first instance of Desire tampering with Dream’s love life. The premise is the sort of thing few besides Gaiman would think of and still fewer could pull off: a conference of stars at the near-beginning of the universe, to set boundaries and rules. Making Sol the awkward kid of the bunch warmed my heart.

The weak spot was Death’s entrance on page 66, for reasons that go beyond that particular scene. Consider the common literary topos, “Death will come for each and every one of us in the end.” Gaiman wrote a beautiful story about that: “The Sound of Her Wings,” Sandman #8. The first I ever read. He’s felt the need to repeat himself a few too many times since. On page 66, the whole thing could have been handled much better with fewer words and more innuendo. The facial expressions of the stars say plenty by themselves.

“Fifteen Portraits of Despair”
Art by Barron Storey and Dave McKean

I’ve never liked Despair. Duh. What I mean is that, unlike the villain that you love to hate, I’ve never even wanted to see Despair or read stories that involve her. Even in that I’m probably not alone, and maybe it’s even intentional. The best of the portraits are number three (harrowing in its simplicity) and number thirteen (so sad it’s funny, so funny it’s sad). I have no use for the ones that try to just describe Despair, rather than evoking her with a story or something else concrete. These need to be sustained primarily by the art, and none of that is particularly to my taste.

“Going Inside”
Art by Bill Sienkiewicz

This story is almost impossible to understand on first reading, which, considering that it’s about Delirium, may be appropriate. Great lettering keeps the five different crazy people straight. Gaiman is showing off here, with his ability to juggle the internally consistent, stream-of-consciousness monologues of five different madpeople. Good stuff. We have another perfect matching of visual style to theme (page 119, for example, is just fantastic.) Even the resolution — what exactly do they do to rescue her? — remains somewhere just beyond the realm of the understandable. Here, as with Dream’s tale, it helps a little to have some context and know why Delirium disappeared into herself in the first place. It ends with both a miracle and a happy ending, giving us a touch of delight amid the madness.

“On the Peninsula”
Art by Glenn Fabry

This story recycles the “the Endless are irresistibly fascinating to mortals” schtick again, which is one time too many in a single volume. In the first two stories, the person enthralled — the soldier, the chieftain’s wife — have a particular connection to the the Endless that they meet. What’s our archaeologist’s affinity with Destruction, though? Or maybe that’s the point — he’s turned his back on his calling, and no longer embodies his domain. In any case, it’s a pretty good story. The best thing about Fabry’s panels are the subtle hints of characterization, like Stanley checking out the other woman on page 127. I think I prefer his people as drawn at a distance to his close-ups.

“Endless Nights”
Art by Frank Quitely

This story was the one big disappointment of the batch. Not because the drawings aren�t beautiful — they are. But there’s no story here. All we have is a recyling of the whole “this is Destiny; this is what he does” bit that has already appeared in at least two Sandman issues that I can think of. It would have been great to see an actual story involving Destiny: someone strange visits his garden, maybe, or something tries to steal his book. What we get isn’t so much a story as as an extraneous epilogue.

So the good stuff is definitely frontloaded, but that doesn’t mean it ain’t great. I was a bit too harsh when I said earlier that it was only the art, not the stories, that made Endless Nights a great book. The stories of Death, Desire, Dream, and Delirium rank up there with the best of Gaiman’s comics work. Here’s hoping this isn’t the last time he pays the world of Sandman a visit.

Watching the Foote-ball

Earlier today, I turned to my friend Nick and said: “I feel like an anthropologist encountering a bizarre new culture.”

He replied: “You mean, American culture?”

We were at his house, watching the sport of foote-ball on a Sunday afternoon, something I hadn’t done in . . . well, I’m not certain I’ve ever done it, really. Mind you, this was Nick?s house, so it wasn’t the normal, wussy sort of foote-ball-watching that I assume most patriotic Americans engage in on Sunday afternoons. Nick has a refrigerator in his basement with a spigot on the outside connected to a keg on the inside. For the watching of the foote-ball, he puts a second, smaller TV underneath the big one in the entertainment center. Both of them are hooked up to DirecTV, so that they can be tuned to any of the games that are playing nationwide. Naturally, he also has a TiVo so that the big TV can be rewound when necessary and is constantly recording content on two different channels. Then there’s the laptop, wirelessly connected to broadband, which sits on the coffee table. It’s hooked up to a DirecTV website that constantly updates stats on the running football games, and flashes red under games when exciting things are happening or are about to happen.

The result of all this is a constantly shifting and (to me) utterly baffling parade of football footage across the screen. Without a mind trained and weathered by years of foote-ball, I quickly lost track of which game was on or whether what we were watching was live or, thanks to the TiVo, occurring at some previous point in the timestream.

The games themselves were interesting enough, but the lead-ins, lead-outs, and pre-game hooplah were another matter entirely. It appears that television sports execs actively seek out all the producers and directors that MTV has rejected for being “too frenetic” and “too busy.” (These must be the same people that boldly pioneered the use of animated gifs in web design in the 90s.) No stat, picture, or sidebar is complete without one of the several thousand different whooshing sounds that the networks have at their disposal. By far the most disturbing sight, though, was the pregame practice of having the commentators reenact a play from some previous game on a little make-believe football field in their studio. Now, I’ve watched enough of the foote-ball in my life to know that this practice has got to be relatively new. Who in Sam Hill thought this up? It’s not like these guys actually redo the play, because they’re all ex-jocks with joints primed to crumble into dust at a moment’s notice, so they lurch around awkwardly like poor saps from the audience dragged onto the stage of an improv show. Fortunately they lighten the moment by making wise cracks about touching each other’s butts — oh no, wait, that actually makes it infinitely more disturbing.

All that aside, I still enjoyed myself, though I have grown envious of foote-ball fans. Clearly they possess a special, extra compartment in their brain devoted to storing foote-ball trivia and statistics. I assume this must be the case because if I had to retain the amount of lore they are able to draw upon at a moment’s notice, it would quickly edge out other important data such as the complete lyrics to “It’s the End of the World As We Know It,” the fact that Thundarr the Barbarian’s sidekicks are named Ariel and Ookla, and how to brush my teeth.

I can’t say I’ll be back every Sunday afternoon. OK, probably not even intermittently. Maybe for the Superbowl. For the commercials. But in the meantime, I wish all foote-ball watchers and players the very best. Wear your gloves proudly and keep your eye on the puck!

Waiting for Kaluta

Baltimore Comicon was great fun, though for me it was the fun of a tourist and sometime comics reader, not an aficianado or collector. I expected a bit more in the way of costumed attendees, but the only one I managed to get a picture of was this guy, who I’m pretty sure is meant to be Green Lantern. He was walking around in a completely different and somewhat more disturbing Green Lantern costume later on in the Con, too.

Not being someone who has a reason to browse bins of used comics, I spent my time on the other side of the floor, where the artists were hanging out, signing comics and often doing sketches. It struck me that the artists, much more than the writers, tend to be the icons of comics fandom. Part of that must be convention-driven, in the sense that an artist can do a sketch and sell his or her artwork, whereas a writer could sign stuff and chat but probably couldn’t, say, churn out a quick snatch of dialogue on spec. But it clearly goes beyond that. In a mental tally of Big Names in Comics I’m familiar with, the cause celebre artists easily outnumber the writers. Historically, this is as it should be – it’s not like Golden and Silver age comics distinguished themselves with rich, original plots and nuanced characterizations. But as someone who is far more sensitive to subtleties in the writing than in the drawing, I would have liked to see Brian Michael Bendis there in the booth alongside Michael Avon Oeming. (It would also be nice to see them spin off their pretentious third names and give someone named Michael Avon a shot at fame, but that’s a different issue.)

By far the best time spent at the Con was the long hour waiting in line with my dear friends Joe and Julia so Joe could get Michael Kaluta to sign a couple books and do a sketch. Everything I know about Kaluta I learned in that hour, but I quickly got the picture – here was one of the old greats, a superlative artist who had been working for decades, but far from being jaded, was still a great sport at the cons. It was (to Joe’s mind and, consequently, to mine) a travesty that only a handful of folks were waiting to see him while the line for Jim Lee (young punk!) snaked on and on and on.

It was tremendous fun watching Kaluta (here’s what he looks like) turn out sketch after sketch for the people in front of us. He’d take fifteen minutes or so for each one, all the while chatting amicably with the people in line. The casual, almost careless way he turned out the sketches belied their grace and precision.

For the most part I kept my mouth shut, because, though I am by no means shy, I suck when it comes to making chitchat with strangers – especially strangers you’re a fan of, which I was by the time we got around to the front of the line. Here’s me trying to make small talk with Michael Kaluta:

NB: (blurting at an inopportune moment) Hey, uh, we met your brother – oh, uh, I mean, we were talking to Steve Conley and how he met your brother at this coffee shop in Arlington. Common Grounds. You’re, uh, from Arlington, right?
MK: (smiling politely) Yeah, I heard about that.

(awkward silence)

Now here’s Joe (I’m replacing actual names and terms that I didn’t jot down with comparable stand-ins):

JP: You know, I’ve always felt that the art of Varn Flarn was influenced by Tringo Wiskbasket in a way that reminds me of your work in the Book of Foo MgGoo.
MK: Yes, yes, absolutely!
JP: In light of that, what do you think about the future of Quantam Colorific ZingZang in the work of Quaffle, Biddy, and Wort?
MK: Well, it seems to me that . . . (talks for ten minutes about all sorts of interesting stuff that goes way over my head.)

I didn’t know who impressed me more – Kaluta for the amazing Galadriel sketch he turned out while talking a blue streak, or Joe for always having something insightful and relevant to say or ask to keep Kaluta talking. By the end I was snapping a picture of Joe, Julia, and Kaluta looking for all the world like lifelong friends.

I had been aware of the existence of a librarian action figure from the news, but took little interest. My sole purchase of the day, however, was a librarian action figure on a whole ‘nother level.

Coming some time this week: actual video footage of the legendary Steve Conley being funny!

A New View

The modest “crack” of last night turns out to have been masking a much bigger catastrophe: two magnificent trees, whose upper branches were even with the ninth floor, both fallen. One is laying on top the other now, and I’d be tempted to say that the first knocked the second down, except that both of them tipped over right at the base, where the roots failed to hold. Here are some pictures:

  • This is the view of the first tree through the apartment window.
  • This is the same tree from the ground, facing the building.
  • This is the base of the second tree.
  • Here’s a shot where you can see both of them.

I’m fairly bummed about this, because they were big, beautiful trees that made for a pleasant view. There’s still plenty of foliage across the way, but we now have a much nicer vantage point with which to observe traffic on Route 50. Whoopee. There’s an up side, though: once they get the trees cleared out and landscape a bit, that lawn will be perfect for bocce or croquet.