Fair and Balanced

The following is presented in celebration of Fair and Balanced Day.

Fair:

Balanced:

Not Fair:

  • Broken AC in D.C. in mid-August
  • Life (according to my mom, as a reply to “That’s not fair!” — “Life isn’t fair.” Spoken with a certain amount of triumphalism.)

Not Balanced:

Neither Fair Nor Balanced:

My Neal Gnome

Every time I see somebody reading Neal Stephenson’s Cryptonomicon, an invisible gnome perched on my shoulder whispers to me: “Hey! Isn’t it time you reread it?”

I smile patiently at the gnome and reply: “Look, I’ve read the book three times. That’s two extra readings, adding up to about 1800 pages, which could have been used on 4-6 other novels. I’m going to read something else.”

To which the gnome replies: “Phooey.”

I saw my buddy French reading it the other day, but this time, the gnome had an ace up its sleeve. “Oh-ho,” it said, “His new novel Quicksilver is coming out in a little more than a month. It’s a prequel of sorts to you-know-what. And it’s been a while since you’ve read it now, hasn’t it? And you’re going to want to have it all fresh in your head, won’t you?”

“Yes, gnome,” I replied dutifully.

“Plus, reread Snow Crash while you’re at it, for kicks,” said the gnome.

What can I say? The gnome was right.

So I’m two-thirds of the way through Snow Crash, which is holding up remarkably well. In 1992 it was incredibly prescient, and eleven years later it’s still amazing how many future trends Stephenson gets right, albeit through the gonzo lens of his over-the-top world, a sort of libertarian hell. I mean that not in the sense that it would be hell for libertarians, but that it’s the kind of hell that rampant extreme libertarianism might create – everything privatized to pieces, the rule of law rendered meaningless. The course of history has taken a different route, though, to where the greater threat is not the erosion of societal structures into the seething biomass, but the intrusive actions of an overzealous federal government. Stephenson didn’t foresee the role of international terrorism, or the potential repercussions of an event like 9/11.

He also failed to anticipate SUVs, and spends a lot of energy mocking “bimbo boxes” (minivans), which now comes off as quaint. But in many matters both technological and cultural, he gets things right, and in any case he never set the novel up to be a prophetic one, and it’s probably unfair to judge it significantly on those grounds. Any book with characters like Raven and Uncle Enzo can certainly stand on its own merits without having to tell the future as well.

After I’m done I’ll tackle Cryptonomicon again, with pleasure. Quicksilver comes out on September 23. I fired off an email to Slashdot to see if they want me to write a review of it for them, like I did for Cryptonomicon. I’m betting they probably have somebody else lined up for it, in which case I’ll write something spiffy up for Polytropos instead.

UPDATE: OK, maybe Stephenson captured overzealous feds too. Just got through Chapter 37, a description of Fedland, where Y.T.’s mom works. Hilarious and terrifying.

Numinous Potter?

Dan of dislogue shares a penchant with Polytropos for prattling on about Potter. His entry sounds off from this one by A.C. Douglas, who liked the books in a general way but agreed with A.S. Byatt that Rowling is missing the �numinous�:

I’m saying merely that in each of the first four volumes I’ve read, there came a point in the narrative that fairly pleaded, cried out even, for a deft suggestion of some deeper mystery behind the outward magic . . . But instead, in each case, the plea went unacknowledged and unanswered, with the unhappy result that the books are experienced as a mere entertainment and diversion of the moment . . .

Dan helpfully stops to ask just what is meant by �numinous.� Douglas is looking for �deeper mystery behind the up-front magic,� Byatt calls for a �shiver of awe,� and Dan rightly notes that there�s something almost spiritual in those definitions � at any rate, something that seems to be governed more by one�s emotional response to the work more than anything else.

It gets thornier, though. I quibbled with Byatt when she accused the Potter books of lacking numinosity, precisely because I had experienced a �shiver of awe,� or at least a shiver of something, at those key moments in reading them. Unlike Douglas, I didn�t perceive a plea that went unanswered � whether that�s because I had a stronger emotional reaction, or just different expectations, I don�t know.

But there�s a difference between �profound emotional reaction� and numinous in the �deep magic� sense, and here I�d agree with Douglas, and Dan, and even (gasp!) Byatt. If numinous implies addressing some fundamental deeper meaning, then Potter ain�t it. Maybe �mythopoeic� is a better word than �numinous� to use here, though it�s just as fraught with different associations. Strictly speaking it means �having to do with or seeking to invoke myths,� though it�s often uttered in the same breath as �Tolkien� or �Lewis.� Mythpoeic, for me, implies fantasy that seeks resonance by invoking mythic archetypes. (My copy of Tolkien’s “On Fairy Stories” is lent out right now, otherwise I’d have more to say about mythopoeia and his notion of “recovery”. But I don’t want to get it wrong.) In any case, mythopoeia is not necessarily governed by the emotional response of the audience, although of course, if rightly done, it should invoke a deep reaction.

Mythopoeia implies something not just about tone or subject matter, but about plot. And that�s where I see a big difference between Potter and mythopoeic fantasy. Douglas� comparison of Rowling to Conan Doyle is apt; strip away the fantastic trappings, and the plots of the Potter novels resemble detective novels more than anything else. They are intricate, full of early clues with later payoffs, hidden identities, and logical puzzles. Even magic in Rowling�s world works under fairly predictable rules, and revelations about new curses and enchantments usually arise to provide plot complications and resolutions, not to reveal something about the underlying nature of the world. In the first book I was delighted with this simply because it was nice to see someone writing children’s lit who didn’t underestimate their appetite for story. By the second book it annoyed me because part of me was looking for mythpoeic fantasy, and by the third it was clear that Rowling’s game was something a little different, which was fine. In fact, when Rowling tries to get all big-picturey on us, as with the explanation of the prophecy at the end of Book Five, she usually falters.

Dan looks for folks to compare Rowling to, and comes up with Robert Asprin and Terry Pratchett. These fit sometimes in terms of tone, and with a fast-and-loose but still loving attention to the secondary world. Classic children�s fantasy merits some comparisons, but a lot of it (Cooper, Lewis) is mythopoeic, while the Potter books certainly aren�t. I�m hard pressed to come up with a comparison for Rowling that accounts for the mix she brings to the table. Which is another way of saying, I suppose, that what she�s doing isn’t derivative at all, but quite unique.

We Missed You, JS

The relationship of Polytropos HQ with the local cable company has always been troubled. My struggle with the annoying cable box they installed is a long story that probably shouldn’t go on the Web. We pay for bare-bones cable, the option you pick if you want good reception for the network channels, but not much else. A few days ago, the cable powers switched around the channels and made who knows what other changes, and by some strange alchemy of the airwaves, we now have Comedy Central, which hasn’t been the case since we had full cable in our old apartment three years ago.

That’s why we sat in muted, almost reverend anticipation at 10:59, waiting for the one piece of television we had sorely missed all those years: The Daily Show. And I’m happy to report that Jon Stewart has still got the moxy. The show hasn’t lost its edge — how could it, really, with the current Administration proving such fertile ground for satire?

The Daily Show is immediately preceded by the Man Show, which, as some of you may know, traditionally rounds out its broadcast by displaying scantily clad women bouncing up and down on trampolines. I am loath to miss even a moment of Stewart’s opening, since it’s usually the best part of the show, but Suanna will not, under any circumstances, allow us to watch even a millisecond of girls on trampolines just for the sake of not missing any of what follows. This creates a slight logistical problem, but nothing that a bit of planning and some carefully synchronized timepieces can’t fix.

Baby Gear

Amazon customer reviews are a literary genre in their own right. But if you think you know all about them from the idle surfing you’ve done in search of a new book or CD, you’re wrong. You haven’t checked out the Baby Store yet.

The rules are entirely different in the Baby Store. There, reviews are part product commentary, part message board, and part personal narrative. To properly write a product review in the baby store, you must mention the age, weight, and general disposition of your infant, and also clarify whether or not you have any other children. Your child may be referred to simply as “baby,” or, more rarely, as “my son” or “my daughter”. You get bonus points for referring to yourself as “mommy,” in the third person. (I don’t know if this holds true for fathers as well, because I wasn’t able to find a review written by a man.)

Over in the Book Store and Music Store, you’ll find dozens of short-paragraph reviews, interspersed with monster essays by shoppers with a lot of ideas and no place to put them down. But one thing they all have in common is that they’re not really reading the other reviews; they’re just sounding off on their own. Over in Babyland, the reviews form an ongoing conversation. They’re full of references to other reviews, agreements, disagreements, clarifications, and expansions. It’s clear that there’s much more of a community thing going on over there, albeit a twee, slightly kooky community.

Classic example, from the crib section (all sic):

This crib is one of the best baby item’s I have ever received! My mother purchased this crib for me when I was 7 months pregnant with my first child (who is now 4.5 years old) I must say that at first I was a little upset that I did not get to buy my own crib, you know the first time mom syndrome, where you have to have the “most expensive” everything! Well let me say that I was wrong!

This crib is one of the cheapest on the market, however I have had NO COMPLAINTS about it what-so-ever. I have put this crib together and taken it apart 3 different times. Each time I was pregnant, and had no help from my furniture assembly challenged husband. Crib mattresses, (we just purchased #3, for our 3rd baby) have all fit very snug, with no gaps.

I’d like to call special attention to the “furniture assembly challenged husband” comment. Maybe I’m a bit paranoid, but it seems like the group consensus over in Amazon Babyville is that husbands are, by and large, an obstacle to be overcome in raising children and acquiring gear. The “my husband and I love it!” comments are there, but few and far between.

Why don’t guys have a bigger presence in the world of baby gear chitchat? We are talking about gear, after all. Some of the stuff is pretty darn cool, with as many moving parts and different configurations as the Decepticons. Figuring out which suite of gear to get is a sort of programming challenge — crib or pack ‘n’ play? cloth or disposable? Separate stroller and car seat, or modular travel system? Whats the optimal amount of gear, in terms of space and weight, to fit into the house/apartment? I can happily spend two hours surfing for digital camera reviews and specs, but after half an hour of baby-gear analysis, my eyes start to glaze over. Why? It doesn’t make sense.

I blame the pastels.

UPDATE: In email, my mom pointed out that this entry is mistitled. Clearly, the title ought to be “Crib Notes.” Thanks, mom. Wish I had thought of it.

Good Riddance, Mr. Taylor

The situation in Liberia has calmed down. Charles Taylor is in exile in Nigeria. That doesn’t mean it’s all better there, or that there’s not going to be more ugliness in the future. But the current crisis has been defused, and that has occurred as a direct result of international intervention.

I wrote earlier that I would have much preferred American and not Nigerian troops on the ground. What we actually got was something of a compromise — West African forces, mostly Nigerian, with the U.S. watching over their shoulder, to be followed by a U.N. mission. Better than nothing. Actual U.S. troops would have been preferable, not least because it would go a little ways toward creating the impression that the U.S. government gives a damn about what happens in Liberia. (I’d prefer that they actually did give a damn, but again — better than nothing.)

I never bought the argument that sending Marines into Liberia would further tax the resources of a military that’s already spread thin. The U.S. already had three warships off the coast — total crew about 1800, with capacity for 1800 Marines. Keeping them there has got to be plenty expensive by itself — how much more of a dent would sending 1300 Marines into Monrovia have made? That’s how many ECOMIL troops arrived at first, leading to an immediate cessation of hostilities. Their casualties? None. Had there been anyone inclined to attack peacekeepers, which apparently there weren�t, they’d be even less inclined to attack U.S. troops than Nigerian ones.

What has struck me most about the whole conflict, even more than combatants in drag, is the way the fighting stopped immediately as soon as ECOMIL forces arrived at the airport. There was wide reporting of the scene of rebel and government forces embracing at the scene of a bridge they had just been fighting over. It seemed a very Liberian moment to me, not because it fit some neat definition of “Liberian-ness,” but precisely because it was such an unpredictable relief. Living there, surreal surprises of horror and delight were constant fixtures.

I’ve said it before, I’ll say it again. I’m not suggesting that intervention is always or even often the right solution — just that it was right for Liberia right now.

Found . . .

. . . in the back of my wallet: a fortune cookie fortune from the day I started Polytropos.

In silence man can most readily preserve his dignity.

Whoops.

Tournament Aftermath

If any readers find themselves preparing for the National Championship of a collectible card game, I can offer them some solid advice, borne of experience:

Lesson One:

If you haven’t played the game regularly in four years or so, and you look back at some of your old deck designs, and they seem a little odd to you, do not assume that with a bit of fiddling around you can improve them now. You are older and stupider than you were then, and you don’t know the game as well as you once did. Rely upon your past judgment.

Lesson Two:

The night before you leave, when you say to yourself, “Maybe I should go through my tournament decks to make sure that all the right cards are there and I’m not leaving anything behind,” listen to yourself. Do not say “Nah — I�m sure everything’s groovy” and go to bed.

Lesson Three:

Pay attention to the location of the tournament. If the web site says that the tournament is at the “Game Parlor,” for example, look at the address even if you’ve been there many times before. This could be important — for example, if a new Game Parlor store had opened up forty minutes away, and that’s where the tournament was actually being held.

Yesterday was glorious fun, even though I got my butt kicked. In the five rounds of semifinals, I won twice, lost twice, and tied once, which was downright lucky given my sloppy decks and the cards I accidentally left behind. I thought there would be a number of people like me, who had “retired” and were playing for the first time in a while; I was wrong. The game is far more active than what I had guessed — lots of folks still play online, and wondered where the heck I had been all this time. There were quite a few people who had even started playing the game in the past couple years. Three people flew in all the way from California.

So I was thoroughly humbled, but in a very encouraging way, if that makes any sense. It was a fine thing to see old friends and acquaintances, and very satisfying to see that the game itself still has staying power. A big reason why is the dynamics of the metagame — over time, powerful tactics rise to the fore, but as the player base gets wise to them and adjusts the way they build decks accordingly, those tactics become ineffective. Correctly predicting what strategies your opponents are likely to follow is one of the hardest and most important skills for winning tournaments. And it keeps the game from getting stale.

After all the tension of the semifinals, the evening was much more relaxed, and included some rousing rounds of Middle Earth: the Drinking Game. In the wee hours, sobering up, I helped my buddy Josh, who had made the top four, figure out what deck he was going to bring to Finals the next day. I’m hoping Josh will win, but I don’t know yet if he did — this morning, after a smallish amount of sleep, staying in bed sounded far more attractive than rising at eight to drive down to Woodbridge in time for the sealed deck tournament. Gettin’ old, I guess.

I can hear the siren call of MECCG, now. There are enough active players that it could be every bit as challenging and fun as it was in the old days, if I wanted to get back into it. I won’t — my gaming plate is full these days without it — but it’s a fine thing that it’s still going strong.